Example Audit — Halo Color Cosmetics

<\!-- Hero -->

Halo

Color Cosmetics & Complexion

halobeautystudio.co

Audit Complete Omnisend · Shopify ⚠

D+

Poor

Halo has exactly what beauty brands need to win on email — a visual product, strong UGC, a community-first brand voice, and customers who want to hear from them. The problem is everything downstream of that. Omnisend is limiting deliverability and automation capability. Four of five core flows are missing. Email contributes roughly 12% of revenue when top-quartile color cosmetics brands drive 30–34%. That gap is $28,500/mo — the largest opportunity we've quantified this year at this revenue level.

<\!-- Platform Alert Card -->

Platform Alert: Omnisend Detected — Migration Recommended

Omnisend's automation capabilities and deliverability infrastructure are significantly below Klaviyo's for a brand at Halo's revenue level. Missing flow types (browse abandonment, multi-step post-purchase, advanced winback) aren't configurable on Omnisend's base tier. Before investing in flow builds, migrate to Klaviyo — the ROI improvement from migration alone typically recovers the cost within 30 days for brands doing over $500K/mo.

<\!-- Dollar Gap Callout -->

Revenue Left on the Table

~$28,500/mo

Halo's traffic and brand equity support a fully-realized email program. The current setup captures a fraction of what's available — primarily because 4 of 5 core flows don't exist yet.

~$1.5M Est. monthly revenue

~12% Current email contribution (Omnisend)

~14% Est. contribution with flows fixed

~$28,500 Monthly flow gap

<\!-- Share Bar --> <\!-- Scorecard Section -->

6-Point Scorecard

Every gap is a revenue leak. Here's exactly where Halo's are.

<\!-- Welcome Flow: F -->

Welcome Flow

Critical — Missing

Not configured. Halo's strongest asset — the brand community, the shade-matching content, the 'beauty as self-expression' positioning — is introduced to new subscribers exactly once: the Omnisend opt-in confirmation. After that, silence. Beauty brands with a strong community have the highest Welcome email open rates of any vertical (83.6% on email 1, per Omnisend 2025). Halo is not activating this. Every week without a Welcome Series is a week of new subscribers who never got a reason to buy.

→ Build 3-email Welcome Series: brand voice + shade philosophy in Email 1, bestseller spotlight with UGC in Email 2, shade-match incentive in Email 3

💰 Revenue opportunity: ~$6,800/mo — from welcome-to-purchase conversion on a flow Halo's brand equity should drive at 8–12%

<\!-- Abandoned Cart: D -->

Abandoned Cart

Poor

Omnisend's basic cart recovery is active — one email fires at 2 hours. Cart abandonment rate for beauty is 81.7% (highest of any vertical), and Halo's average cart value is $68. A single generic email captures 4–6% of recoverable revenue. A 3-email recovery sequence with shade-specific copy (referencing the exact shade in the cart) typically doubles recovery rate for color cosmetics. Omnisend can't configure this level of personalization without upgrading or migrating.

→ Migrate to Klaviyo; build 3-email recovery with shade-aware copy, application tip in email 2, and UGC social proof in email 3

💰 Revenue opportunity: ~$4,200/mo — from improved cart recovery rate and shade-specific personalization

<\!-- Post-Purchase: F -->

Post-Purchase

Critical — Missing

Not configured beyond Shopify order confirmation. Color cosmetics has an unusually high post-purchase education opportunity — how to apply, how to build a look, what else pairs with what they just bought. A 'how to use your new palette' email sent 2 days after delivery converts browsers into loyalists. A tutorial series that builds product mastery drives 60–70% open rates and reduces returns. None of this is happening for Halo's buyers.

→ Build 4-email post-purchase: application tutorial → look-building content → cross-sell into brushes/setting spray → review request with UGC capture

💰 Revenue opportunity: ~$5,100/mo — from second-purchase prompts, reduced returns, and UGC generation that lifts site conversion

<\!-- Browse Abandonment: F -->

Browse Abandonment

Critical — Missing

Not configured. This is Halo's single highest-ROI missing flow. Beauty has the highest browse-to-purchase consideration rate, and Halo's product photography and shade range are strong enough to re-close hesitant visitors. A browse abandonment email for color cosmetics that includes shade swatches, a 'looks with this palette' teaser, and a link back to the exact product converts at $3–8 per email sent for comparable brands. Zero of that is happening.

→ Set up 2-email browse flow: shade spotlight + 'how to wear it' at 4h; UGC looks + social proof at 24h

💰 Revenue opportunity: ~$8,600/mo — estimated from subscriber browse volume on palette and foundation pages × $4.50/email sent benchmark

<\!-- Winback: F -->

Winback

Critical — Missing

Not configured. Beauty buyers purchase every 30–60 days and respond strongly to replenishment-based re-engagement. A winback email that fires at 45 days and references the specific product purchased ('running low on that foundation?') consistently reactivates 8–12% of lapsed buyers for color cosmetics brands. Halo has no re-engagement attempt after purchase — every customer who doesn't self-initiate a second visit is simply gone.

→ Build 3-email replenishment-based winback: running-low nudge at 45 days → new shades announcement at 60 days → final offer at 75 days

💰 Revenue opportunity: ~$3,800/mo — from reactivation of lapsed buyers at typical beauty replenishment window

<\!-- List Hygiene: D -->

List Hygiene

Poor

Omnisend provides basic contact management but no engaged/unengaged segmentation at the level Klaviyo offers. Campaigns are sending to the full list without suppression of cold addresses. The result: Halo's apparent email deliverability is degrading gradually — inbox placement rates on Omnisend drop as cold address ratios increase. By the time a migration happens, there's cleanup work needed. Migrating sooner reduces the recovery time.

→ Migrate to Klaviyo before building additional flows; use migration as the forcing function for list re-permission and suppression setup

<\!-- Upsell Module -->

Welcome Series Build — $299

Want this Welcome Series live in your Klaviyo this week?

$299 — we build all 3 emails to your brand voice, hand off Klaviyo-ready in 5 business days. No call required.

Custom-written for your store's voice and products
Designed HTML + plain text variants
Subject lines and preview text for all 3 emails
Klaviyo-ready file exports, ready to import
One full revision round included. Money-back if it doesn't ship.

Buy the build — $299 Or book a free strategy call →

<\!-- Welcome Series Section -->

Halo — Custom Welcome Series

Written in Halo's voice. Shade-match positioning, UGC-forward social proof, and the look-building angle beauty subscribers respond to. Ready to import into Klaviyo today.

<\!-- Email 1 -->

Email 1 Immediately after opt-in

Subject Color as a language. Welcome to Halo.

Preview What we believe about makeup — and why it shapes everything we make.

You just joined a community that takes color seriously. Not seriously in a studied, restrained way. Seriously in the sense that we believe color is a form of language — one you've been speaking since the first time you tried on a shade that felt like yourself. Halo started with a different premise from most cosmetics brands: the average woman isn't a professional MUA who needs 14-step application tutorials. She's someone who knows what she likes, wants it to work, and doesn't have 45 minutes in the morning. So we built products that perform without instruction. Pigments formulated for one-pass payoff. Foundations that blend without a beauty blender. Eye looks that photograph well under office lighting, not just studio lighting. And we built a community around helping people find their language. The shade range isn't a catalog decision — it's a commitment to inclusivity that we've extended further than most indie brands our size can manage. We think that matters. This week: explore the collection. Start with the bestsellers. Then, if you want, take the shade quiz. It's two minutes and it's genuinely useful. — The Halo Team P.S. In a few days we'll show you the looks our community is creating right now. Worth seeing.

<\!-- Email 2 -->

Email 2 2 days after opt-in

Subject The looks our community built this month

Preview Real customers. Real shades. What's landing right now.

We let our community build this email. Every month, we compile the looks our customers are tagging us in — the everyday looks, the event looks, the 'I'm trying something new' looks. Because the most useful thing we can show you is what real people are doing with our products, not what a model in controlled lighting is doing. Here's what's landing right now: → The five-minute face Foundation in Warm Ivory or Warm Sand (depending on undertone), Blush in Petal + Highlighter in Sunrise. Takes 5 minutes. Photographs clean. It's the most-shared combo this month, and it works because all three are formulated to complement each other. → The editorial eye Matte Shadow in Ember + Liner in Onyx + the Lengthening Mascara. Our community is using this as both a full smoky build and a subtle daytime look by varying the application pressure. One palette, two directions. → The no-foundation skin Tinted SPF 40 + Concealer in Almond + Setting Powder in Translucent. The brand that told you foundation was mandatory didn't make a Tinted SPF this good. If you've been waiting to try your first Halo product, the five-minute face is the place to start. Warm Ivory and Petal are both in stock. Explore bestsellers → [CTA] — The Halo Team P.S. Still not sure about your foundation shade? Our shade quiz takes 2 minutes and gets it right 91% of the time.

<\!-- Email 3 -->

Email 3 4 days after opt-in

Subject Find your shade. 15% off when you do.

Preview Take the shade quiz → get a recommendation → save 15% on your first order.

Here's how this works. Take the shade quiz. It asks four questions about your undertone, coverage preference, and finish. At the end, it recommends your exact foundation match. Add it to your cart. Apply at checkout: the 15% off is already applied. No code needed. Order expires 48 hours from when this email arrived. Why are we doing this? Because the biggest drop-off point for new beauty customers isn't price — it's uncertainty about the right shade. This removes the uncertainty, removes the cost barrier, and gives you a specific reason to try the product that was matched to you. If you already know your shade, use the 15% on whatever's on your list. It applies to everything. Find your shade + save 15% → [CTA] After this, you're on the main list. New launches, community looks, early access to limited-edition releases. Thanks for being here. — The Halo Team P.S. If the quiz recommends a shade and it's not quite right, we'll exchange it, no questions asked. We've built the refund policy around the fact that foundation shade is genuinely hard to get right online.

<\!-- Klaviyo Export Card (demo) -->

Download Klaviyo-ready JSON

Free with every audit · Import in 20 min

Every audit includes a Klaviyo-ready JSON file with all 3 Welcome Series emails — subjects, preview text, and responsive HTML. Download the demo to see exactly what you get.

3-step setup

① Klaviyo → Flows → Create Flow
② Set trigger: Subscribed to List → Newsletter
③ Add 3 email actions — paste copy from the JSON

Download demo JSON (free) Get one for your store →

<\!-- See what your store scores CTA -->

You're looking at an example

See what your store actually scores

Run a free audit on your Shopify store. Get your 6-point scorecard, dollar-gap estimate, and a custom 3-email Welcome Series written in your brand voice. Takes about 90 seconds.

Run your free audit →